Call Now Request FREE consultation - 1866-758-4529

What Evidence to Preserve After a Truck Accident in Texas

What Evidence to Preserve After a Truck Accident in Texas

After a serious injury truck accident, knowing what evidence to preserve, especially after a truck accident in Texas, can be a positive step toward receiving fair compensation for your case.

Unlike regular car-to-car accidents, 18-wheeler and other commercial vehicle crashes can involve federal and state safety regulations that should be preserved for help with your case. Also, you can have multiple parties and vital electronic evidence that needs to be gathered in many cases.

The Texas truck accident lawyer explains the type of evidence and when to act to protect your rights for a personal injury claim.

This guide is designed for truck accident victims, their families, and anyone involved in commercial vehicle crashes during the hours after the wreck. Whether you’re dealing with serious injuries from an 18-wheeler collision or managing the aftermath of a loved one’s fatal accident, knowing what actions to take is vital.

Why Saving Evidence Matters

Evidence preservation is crucial because the burden to prove your case falls upon the injured victim. That requires proof. Some efforts to preserve evidence are more important than others. Evidence, such as surveillance videos, must be obtained before they are overwritten or lost, and then secured quickly. Factual evidence from the collision scene will deteriorate quickly and should be documented promptly.

Not all cases require immediate action to save evidence. When liability is clear, its importance can diminish in some instances. For instance, if you were rear-ended while stopped at a red light, obtaining local surveillance video may not be needed. Also, one must balance the severity of your injuries with the cost of obtaining some information.

Understanding Evidence Preservation in Truck Accidents

Understanding Evidence Preservation in Truck Accidents

Evidence preservation is the legal and practical process of securing proof before it’s lost, altered, or destroyed by trucking companies, insurance adjusters, or the passage of time.

Commercial vehicle accident cases generally involve more relevant evidence than a typical car accident crash. The applicability of federal trucking regulations and the potential for multiple parties, including drivers, motor carriers, maintenance contractors, and cargo shippers. The more serious the injuries in the accident and the number of parties involved increases, the risk of losing evidence increases if it is not quickly secured.

When Quick Action is Required

Security Video-

Surveillance footage from nearby businesses is usually automatically overwritten within 7-30 days (or less) of recording. A business security video can often show exactly what happened in the accident and cut off typical defenses. Too, the scene should be documented before skid marks and other scene evidence deteriorate and are lost.

Documenting the Scene-

In some cases, documenting the scene can be vital to improving your odds for success in a truck accident lawsuit. Places like skid marks, debris, and gouges in the highway. All can be very useful to an accident reconstruction expert in accurately reenacting the crash. Accident reconstruction experts are frequently hired when the liability is disputed or when the trucking defendants blame the victim.

Rain and heavy travel can cause much of a scene to disappear; therefore, documenting the important factual evidence as soon as possible is recommended.

Legal Consequences of Lost Evidence

Evidence that is no longer available is, in many cases, simply a missed opportunity to help prove wrongful conduct. Or violations of regulations. As mentioned earlier, in some cases where liability is not disputed, the lost evidence may not matter much. If the crash is captured on video, either dash cam or otherwise, what happened may not be in dispute.

However, the stronger your case, the better your claim and power in settlement negotiations. If you have evidence of a knowing violation of the regulations or possible punitive damage claims, your case is strengthened substantially through good evidence.

Critical Evidence Types You Should Preserve

Winning a truck accident lawsuit requires the plaintiff to prove their case. Here are critical types of evidence that you must preserve to have the strongest possible case. This evidence can include showing the severity of the crash and the driver’s conduct.

Electronic and Digital Evidence

  • Black box data, also called an electronic control module or event data recorder. It provides proof that it’s hard to dispute matters such as the truck driver’s speed, braking activity, and evasive maneuvers. Obtaining black box data often undermines the defense’s contentions regarding the driver’s speed and actions.
  • Camera footage from dashcams, driver-facing cameras, and nearby surveillance systems captures the driver’s actual behavior before the crash. Many large motor carriers install dashcams in their commercial trucks.
  • GPS tracking records reveal the truck’s route, speed patterns, and any violations of designated trucking corridors or weight restrictions. Electronic logging devices also track hours-of-service compliance and can expose driver fatigue violations that contributed to the accident.
  • Cell phone records prove whether the truck driver was texting, calling, or using apps during the crash, supporting distracted driving claims that significantly increase compensation in truck accident cases.

Driver Documentation and Records

Hours-of-service logbooks show the driver’s time behind the wheel and on the job. Drivers’ logs often reveal rule violations that can lead to driver fatigue and to the trucking company’s negligence in monitoring its drivers.

Post-accident drug and alcohol test results are required within 2-8 hours under Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSA §382.303) for qualifying truck crashes. Alcohol and drug testing results provide critical proof of impairment that can support punitive damages claims worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Driver employment files include training records, prior violations, medical certifications, and CDL license status. Negligent hiring practices or inadequate training by trucking companies can help establish additional liability beyond the individual driver’s actions.

Vehicle maintenance records required under FMCSA §396.3 document whether the truck received proper inspections and repairs. Failure to address mechanical problems that contributed to a crash can constitute the trucking company’s negligence in vehicle safety.

Physical and Scene Evidence

Crash scene photographs or video, including vehicle positions, skid marks, debris patterns, and road conditions, preserve essential details about impact angles, speeds, and environmental factors that contributed to the accident. Physical evidence, such as tire marks, can disappear quickly due to weather and cleanup efforts.

Surveillance footage from nearby businesses, traffic cameras, and other vehicles provides independent verification of crash circumstances. This footage typically gets overwritten within 7 days, making immediate requests to business owners and government agencies essential.

Eyewitness contact information must be collected immediately. Often, accident victims rely upon the investigating officers to document eyewitness accounts. Unfortunately, this does not always happen. Witnesses to the crash can help prove your case and are powerful evidence in a truck accident lawsuit.

Vehicle damage documentation, including detailed photographs and an expert inspection, provides evidence of impact forces, crash severity, and mechanical failures that may have contributed to the accident.

Key Points:

  • Video data from entities not involved in a crash has the shortest preservation window.
  • Physical evidence deteriorates rapidly due to weather and cleanup crews.

Collecting vital evidence after a truck accident often requires the victim or their family to take action. And for more help from a truck accident attorney to secure the most valuable evidence. We recommend that victims or their families interview local attorneys to find the best truck accident attorney. To find the best truck accident law firm for their case.

Step-by-Step: First 24 Hours After an Injury Accident

When to use this: For victims who are conscious and able to act safely at the accident scene or shortly after receiving medical treatment.

  1. Ensure safety and call 911: Document emergency response times, police officer badge numbers, and the responding agency. Request that police measure or photograph skid marks and vehicle positions before cleanup begins.
  2. Photograph everything: Take wide shots of the crash scene, close-ups of vehicle damage, license plates, DOT numbers on commercial trucks, visible injuries, road conditions, traffic signals, and any debris. We suggest focusing on evidence that shows the truck’s condition and the severity of the impact.
  3. Collect witness information: Obtain full names, phone numbers, and addresses of any eyewitnesses. Taking a photo of a witness’s driver’s license can quickly capture contact information.

Comparison: Self-Collection vs Legal Preservation

Evidence TypeSelf-CollectionLegal Preservation
Scene photosCan document immediately     Not applicable
Witness statementsBasic contact info onlyProfessional interviews and written statements
Black box dataNo access possibleRequired through discovery and preservation letters
Driver logsNot accessibleObtained through legal discovery and subpoenas
Maintenance recordsThe company won’t shareDisclosure through discovery in a lawsuit

While victims should collect basic scene evidence immediately if it is safe to do so, the most critical evidence, such as electronic data and corporate records, requires an experienced truck accident lawyer to obtain.

Common Challenges and Solutions

Trucking companies and their insurers often send lawyers, investigators, and experts within hours of serious crashes to document facts they believe may help defend a personal injury or wrongful death claim.

Challenge 1: Trucking Companies Refusing to Share Records

Solution: An experienced truck accident lawyer will send spoliation letters demanding preservation of all electronic data, truck driver logs, maintenance records, and internal communications related to the crash. Admissible and relevant evidence will be obtainable through discovery once a lawsuit has been filed.

Challenge 2: Electronic Data

Solution: Send a preservation-of-evidence letter to the truck driver and the trucking company. Identify and act to obtain surveillance camera footage from nearby businesses or homes.

Challenge 3: Can’t Find Witnesses

Solution: Hire professional investigators to locate and interview witnesses of the crash, obtaining detailed statements.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Evidence preservation must begin as soon as possible after a truck accident to protect your rights and get fair compensation. Attorneys for trucking companies actively work to limit the availability of evidence. The most valuable evidence, including black box records, driver logs, and trucking company records, will require a skilled trucking accident attorney.

To get started:

  1. Contact an experienced truck accident lawyer ASAP for a free consultation to learn your next steps.
  2. Photograph the crash scene and document all vehicle damage if you can do so safely.
  3. Avoid speaking with trucking company representatives or insurance adjusters until you have legal representation to protect your interests.

Related Topics: Understanding truck accident litigation timelines can help you prepare for the legal process ahead, while learning about federal trucking regulations provides context for potential violations that strengthen your truck accident claim.

Contact the Texas Truck Accident Lawyer for a Free Consultation

Our truck accident law firm in Houston has been representing families after a wrongful death and individuals who have been seriously injured in commercial vehicle accidents for more than four decades. We have won hundreds of millions of dollars and have the expertise needed for your truck accident claim.

Call (281) 893-0760

Related Resources:

Post under: blog

About Greg Baumgartner

Truck accident lawyer Greg Baumgartner
Greg Baumgartner is a preeminent rated personal injury lawyer based in Houston, Texas, with over three decades of experience representing severely injured clients in truck accidents. He founded Baumgartner Law Firm, in 1985, with a mission to provide excellent legal representation and personalized attention to every client.